Sorry you two have had such bad luck. As you can tell in the first pic, the gasket fit perfect. Can't say enough about it.
I also ordered a new rear view mirror, a rear step bumper with lights, and the wiring kit for the bumper, all of which were superb quality. Great quality wiring kit and the instructions made it super easy to install. Almost forgot, my new front bumper came from them too. Real nice as well.
